Table 8 SNR improvement vs JSR comparison for PWPT approach based on various optimization algorithms
Jamming type | JSR(dB) | FA | DE | PSO-GSA | SPSO | RPSO | LPSO | IPSO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SCWI | 30 | 37.082 | 37.265 | 37.267 | 37.159 | 37.172 | 37.155 | 37.203 |
40 | 46.521 | 46.479 | 46.533 | 46.495 | 46.548 | 46.481 | 46.611 | |
50 | 54.617 | 54.700 | 54.658 | 54.732 | 54.650 | 54.706 | 54.745 | |
60 | 64.660 | 64.731 | 54.696 | 64.669 | 64.704 | 64.647 | 64.748 | |
MCWI | 30 | 36.746 | 36.877 | 36.885 | 36.799 | 36.851 | 36.820 | 36.914 |
40 | 45.167 | 45.157 | 45.069 | 45.147 | 45.157 | 45.207 | 45.219 | |
50 | 54.691 | 54.704 | 54.726 | 54.759 | 54.708 | 54.716 | 54.786 | |
60 | 64.600 | 64.642 | 64.682 | 64.659 | 64.701 | 64.670 | 64.736 | |
CCWI1 | 30 | 37.877 | 37.902 | 37.910 | 37.843 | 37.960 | 37.957 | 37.969 |
40 | 47.486 | 47.504 | 47.477 | 47.340 | 47.529 | 47.537 | 47.637 | |
50 | 57.075 | 57.155 | 57.187 | 57.171 | 57.151 | 57.165 | 57.230 | |
60 | 66.931 | 66.921 | 66.912 | 66.905 | 66.954 | 66.914 | 67.037 | |
CCWI2 | 30 | 36.980 | 36.923 | 36.898 | 37.178 | 36.986 | 36.971 | 37.222 |
40 | 46.136 | 46.078 | 46.124 | 46.099 | 46.071 | 46.003 | 46.155 | |
50 | 55.112 | 55.126 | 55.161 | 55.154 | 55.057 | 55.158 | 55.226 | |
60 | 64.121 | 64.178 | 64.173 | 64.516 | 64.244 | 64.159 | 64.572 |